Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JD Foster's avatar

Senator Lenney's passion is admirable, as his fine collection of data points. Unfortunately, his data flood don't include the information needed to know whether the Micron deal is good for Idaho or not, or whether the tax breaks make sense or not. To be clear, I don't know the answer to either question, and am no closer to an answer despite Lenney's passion.

Do the tax breaks mean Micron makes the investment, or makes a bigger investment? If so, then you have to ask what property tax revenue would have been paid by the Kuna farmers who would still own the land? How many jobs would there have been had the tax breaks not been in effect and Micron not made the investment?

The clearest case to be made against the tax breaks arises if Micron would have made the same investment, in the same amount, in Idaho without the tax breaks. Micron, like so many companies, certainly has viable alternatives to investing in Idaho.

DAH's avatar

I am deeply saddened by what is happening to our quality of life in the Treasure Valley. The average temperature has risen because farmland has been replaced with concrete and asphalt. Our traffic is starting to rival LA as it becomes more difficult to move from east to west and north to south. And, the county is filled with massive building and infrastructure projects. My little town of Star alone will be tied up with massive road construction (44/16, 44 widening and Star Rd widening) for many years. While I’m grateful for the work, I also know that these new roads will be jammed with traffic the day that they open. Too much too fast. Please give us a break.

No posts

Ready for more?