If your email provider truncates this message then you can read the whole thing on the website.
It’s hard to believe it’s been a whole year since my last Year in Review post. Since that time I’ve more than doubled my subscribers and seen my posts shared far and wide in the world of Idaho conservatives. It’s reached the point now where readers I’ve never met introduce themselves to me at events. It’s a little strange, but fun. I remain humbled and honored by the outpouring of support, and I will continue to do my best to provide you with worthwhile news, analysis, and commentary.
After reporting from the Idaho GOP Winter Meeting in January I announced that I had taken a role with the Idaho Freedom Foundation. In that capacity I had the privilege of hosting Capitol Clarity every Thursday at noon in the Lincoln Auditorium, which remains one of the neatest things I’ve ever done.
Though posting slowed down due to my new commitments, I struck a chord with my comparison of two newly elected state officers, Superintendent Debbie Critchfield and Attorney General Raúl Labrador:
Which Way, Idaho?
Less than a week after flatly declaring that taxpayer money should never leave the public education system, State Superintendent of Public Instruction Debbie Critchfield sent a letter to legislators explaining that while neither the state nor the federal government technically require school districts to adopt woke policies, the threat of litigation fro…
In February I decided to address a tweet of mine that bad actors seized upon as proof that I was some sort of backward misogynistic extremist. I made my first trip to Coeur d’Alene for the KCRCC Lincoln Day extravaganza and had a great time, and also that month I had the honor of meeting Chloe Cole and hearing her story:
Irreversible
Last Thursday, Chloe Cole came to Idaho. Over the course of 24 hours, she spoke to a packed church in Caldwell, visited lawmakers, shared her story at IFF’s Capitol Clarity, was interviewed by KBOI’s Nate Shelman, and recorded a podcast with Wayne Hoffman
In March I learned about the planned Lava Ridge wind farm and asked why the federal government was planning to use Idaho as raw material for Californians. I took the chair of the House Education Committee to task for refusing to allow inappropriate books to be read in her committee hearing, but voting against removing them from public school libraries. It was in March that I wrote perhaps the clearest explanation of my political philosophy, which is that the world we grew up in has changed, and so we must adapt our strategy to fit the current situation:
The Null Hypothesis
I’ve noticed something strange since I came to Idaho nearly five years ago. Many Republicans whose families migrated to this region before Idaho was even a state are the most outspoken voices against what they call extremism. I have heard accusations that issues such as CRT and Queer Theory in public schools were never issues before the great migration …
In April I handed out my entirely subjective legislative awards after watching the entire session from start to finish for the first time. I called out the scapegoating of the 2017 Charlottesville protest and how it’s been treated so differently from the subsequent BLM and Antifa riots. I also celebrated the passage and signing of House Bill 71, banning irreversible surgeries and drugs designed to mutilate healthy children. Last night a federal judge ruled in opposition to this common sense law, so the battle continues.
Culture of Life
Last night, Governor Brad Little did the right thing and signed House Bill 71, protecting children from puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and mutilating surgeries. Leftists are predictably outraged.
In May we went to the polls again, this time deciding on school levies and library boards. I noted that the library has become a cultural battlefield, not because of reactionary conservatives, but because leftists want to capture the hearts and minds of our children. Finally, I shared how my perspective on politics was changed after hearing from Katy Faust, who has made it her mission to persuade us to put children first:
The Next Generation
The very concept of the family is in the process of deconstruction today. We are engaged in a culture war over abortion, homosexuality, polygamy, and transgenderism, all of which confront the questions of “What is life? What is our purpose? What do we have the right to do to ourselves?” On the periphery are issues such as adoption, surrogacy, in-vitro f…
In June I took the bull by the horns, writing full responses to columns by Daniel Silver and Mary Souza that attacked the Idaho GOP and conservatives in general. I ruffled a few feathers when said what is really obvious once you think about it, that achieving your desired political outcome requires political power:
The Politics of Power
Two centuries ago, Carl von Clausewitz described politics as war by other means. More recently, Curtis Yarvin, who wrote political philosophy under the pseudonym Mencius Moldbug, described democracy as a sort of war where two armies take the field, but instead of shooting each other, they take a headcount. Today, too many conservatives still conceive of…
In July I wrote a reminder of why our Founders did what they did and completed my trio of responses with one for Trent Clark. I also called out the disingenuous voices attempting to blame Dorothy Moon and the Idaho GOP for the loss of the March presidential primary:
Who Killed the Presidential Primary?
The Idaho Republican Party last hosted a presidential nominating caucus in 2012, and by all accounts it was a difficult affair. In response, the GOP worked closely with the Legislature to create a primary election in March of 2016. Why March? Because by May, the presidential nomination is usually sewn up, giving candidates no incentive to visit Idaho nor…
Posting was sparse in August, but I still managed to write about the how the middle class taxpayer has become the forgotten man in American discourse. I also took aim at the ranked choice voting / blanket primary initiative that leftists hope to use to fundamentally change the way we vote in Idaho:
Ranked Choice Voting and the Jungle Primary
What is ranked choice voting? What are the real goals of the petition filed by Reclaim Idaho and their allies? Did the Attorney General’s office lose in court last week? Read on to find out: More than ten years ago, the Idaho Republican Party decided to close its primary election. This meant that anyone participating in the Idaho GOP primary must be a re…
In September I wrote a series of posts looking at the failure of the Constitution to prevent the current situation and the futility of appealing to it to fix our current problems. I also indulged my love of history with a fun post about the time Wyatt Earp was a Kootenai County deputy sheriff. It was in September when I decided to take the plunge and try to make a living as an independent writer:
The Next Chapter
It’s time to take Gem State Substack to the next level. I believe there is a pressing need for solid, comprehensive, and independent journalism and political analysis in the Treasure Valley. The response to this publication over the last two years leads me to believe I might be well positioned to fill this need.
Posting picked up in October as I aimed to get one article out every day. A few highlights include my observation that most elected officials see themselves as managers rather than statesmen, my impressions of the Meridian candidate forum, and my visit to the 2nd amendment rally hosted by ISAA. My post breaking the news of mass resignations in the ACRCC became my most read post of all time:
BREAKING NEWS: Ada County GOP Leaders Resign En Masse
On Thursday evening, I headed into Boise for the regular monthly meeting of the Ada County Republican Central Committee (ACRCC). As longtime readers know, I used to be a precinct committeeman but moved down the road and had to resign my seat. I still follow along as an interested observer, and wanted to see the central committee vote on some bylaw chang…
November continued full speed ahead, with another election coming and going. I had the opportunity to ride with an Ada County Sheriff’s deputy for an evening and spend a few hours talking with the one and only Dustin Hurst. The political war in Idaho escalated when Sen. Chuck Winder sent threatening letters to Scott Herndon, Glenneda Zuiderveld and Brian Lenney, stripping the latter two of their vice chairmanships. It was in October that I connected the dots from Governor Brad Little to several PACs that are trying to oust conservative senators:
Is Brad Little Behind Attacks on Conservatives?
Last month, a group called the Idaho Liberty PAC spent nearly $50,000 on literature and staff targeting Senators Tammy Nichols, Chris Trakel, and Brian Lenney, all from Canyon County. What is the Idaho Liberty PAC? Who is funding it? Here are the three door hangers that Idaho Liberty PAC is paying people to spread around Canyon County:
So here we are in another December. 2024 will by all accounts be perhaps the most momentous and tumultuous year in our nation’s history since 1861, so buckle your seatbelts. I have big plans of my own that I’m excited to fully reveal very soon. Make sure you’re subscribed so you don’t miss a moment! Thank you so much for your ongoing support. Let’s tackle 2024 together.