Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Art Macomber's avatar

It’s amazing the ignorance that is demonstrated even by high-level public officials who are against the repeal of the 17th amendment.

This betrays a lack of understanding of the structure of federalism, and by electing senators directly, we are stripping the state legislatures of any say in control of the federal power. Therefore, there is no control over the federal power. This is evident by the last 100 years of the expansion of federal power.

Rather than punish the states forever by removing their check and balance function over the populist reach of the House of Representatives, there should’ve been another solution to the purchasing of senatorial seats.

Further, the people have demonstrated that they will continue to ask more and more of the federal government with no checks on their behavior. The popular vote should be removed from the US Senate, and given back to the state legislatures where it belongs.

No posts

Ready for more?